You’ll Never Guess What’s Inside The Mysterious Box This New Yorker Opened

Matthew Emanuel and his family had lived in their Todt Hill, Staten Island, New York, house for four years. Although they knew every inch of the place, there was one thing that remained a mystery: an old rusted box in the back yard.

After a bad storm, some much need backyard TLC, and a landscaper named Bamboo Bob, the mystery was finally solved, You’ll never guess the chain of events leading up to the opening of the safe, or what Matthew discovered inside.

The Emanuel Family In Todt Hill, Staten Island, New York

The Emanuel Family In Todt Hill, Staten Island, New York
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter

Matthew Emanuel’s family had lived in their Todt Hill home on Staten Island, New York, for four years. In that time they decorated and explored every inch of the place, yet one corner had been left untouched.

In one corner of their backyard, partially stuck in the ground, was the most unassuming structure. The Emanuel family had still not discovered the incredible secret on their property that would soon answer a lot of questions.

A Mysterious Box No One Cared About

A Mysterious Box No One Cared About
CBS New York/Youtube
CBS New York/Youtube

In the Emanuel’s backyard, nestled in the ground by the side of their fence, was a random metal box. Just by looking at it, the family could tell that it hadn’t been moved, let alone touched in a very long time — it was beat up and covered in rust.

Poison ivy also covered the outside of the box, so nobody had bothered to check its contents. The family had even been tossing mulch over it!

A 2018 Winter Storm And Hungry Deer Exposed The Box

A 2018 Winter Storm And Hungry Deer Exposed The Box
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
Spencer Platt/Getty Images

The winter of 2018 had harsh snowstorms, making it so the family had to take notice of the box eventually. Heavy winds caused trees lining their fence to fall over, destroying parts of their backyard while roaming deer came to eat what was left of the vegetation, revealing the mysterious box.

Spring came about, and the family knew they weren’t going to be able to leave their garden in that state. So renovations went underway, meaning the box had to be dealt with.

They Could No Longer Ignore the Box

They Could No Longer Ignore the Box
CityNews Toronto/Toutube
CityNews Toronto/Toutube

It’s not like the box was completely covered at all times. The Emanuel’s could actually see the rusted container from the back windows of their family room as well as from the deck.

For years they hadn’t thought much about the box. It was just one of those things that didn’t seem important enough to demand their immediate attention. Now, with the box clearly out in the open they didn’t really have a choice but to confront the mystery.

Time To Start The Garden Redesign

Time To Start The Garden Redesign
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

The damage the winter storms had caused meant that Matthew was going to have to completely redesign the back garden. To get the job done, he was going to have to work around the old rusted box.

Considering all of the work, he had to search for an expert landscaper. He found someone who seemed like he could get the job done, so he called to make an appointment. Matthew didn’t realize that was the start of an incredible chain of events.

Matthew Hired Bamboo Bob

Matthew Hired Bamboo Bob
Robert Thomas Foley/Youtube
Robert Thomas Foley/Youtube

Matthew hired the landscaper Robert Foley to take on his garden project. Robert, aka Bamboo Bob, made the trip out to Staten Island in late April of 2018. Having experience working across both New York and New Jersey, there’s no shortage of odd things Bob’s seen in his line of work.

Even with all of the escapades that have happened throughout his years working in people’s yards and even zoos, nothing prepared Bob for what he was about to uncover with Matthew.

Bamboo Bob Finds The Box

Bamboo Bob Finds The Box
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter

Matthew’s plan to redesign the garden included putting up a small thicket of bamboo along the side yard. Deer wouldn’t eat it, and it would act as a privacy wall for the family.

As Bamboo Bob and his crew got to work, it was only a matter of time before they stumbled across the rusted box on the side yard. When Bob asked Matthew what the origin story of the box was, he was surprised at his employer’s answer.

Matthew Thought It Was An Electrical Box

Matthew Thought It Was An Electrical Box
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

Having been in enough backyards with bizarre occurrences, Bob couldn’t help but dig up the strange box to find out its purpose. It was getting in the way of their work, anyway, so it was inevitable.

Matthew told them that he assumed it was an electrical box of some kind that was attached to the fence surrounding the property. He couldn’t have been more wrong. What Bamboo Bob and his workers found next would change everything.

The Men Dug Up The Box

The Men Dug Up The Box
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter

Bamboo Bob and his team dug up the box, finally being able to loosen it from the soil. That’s when they knew for certain it was no electrical box, and that Matthew’s assumption about the object for the past four years was incorrect.

Together, the men rotated the box in all directions, trying to figure out what the thing could possibly be. Maybe it was just an old piece of junk that someone meant to throw away.

The Box Turned Out To Be A Safe

The Box Turned Out To Be A Safe
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter

The box had a dial on one of its sides. It was obviously a safe. Bamboo Bob and his team showed it to Matthew who was nothing short of stunned. The four years he and his family had been living in the house, not once had they thought to actually dig the thing up.

The safe had been right under their noses the whole time! Now that they knew what the box was there was only one question left: what was inside?

The Safe Was About 100 Pounds

The Safe Was About 100 Pounds
Matthew Emanual/Twitter
Matthew Emanual/Twitter

The safe was roughly two-feet across and one and a half feet tall, weighing around 100 pounds. Despite its heavy weight, Matthew was determined to find out its contents. After all, he wasted four years not knowing a thing!

Bamboo Bob and his team stood around the garden as they watched Matthew attempt to shift the safe around. He wanted to see if he could hear any of the safe’s contents jostling around inside. He didn’t get far but his efforts didn’t stop there.

Matthew Broke Through The Safe With A Pickaxe

Matthew Broke Through The Safe With A Pickaxe
Howcast/Youtube
Howcast/Youtube

Even with all the shifting, Matthew didn’t hear a thing coming from inside the safe. That didn’t necessarily mean it was empty, though. With the help of his landscaping team, he hoisting the safe up to the deck for further inspection.

The landscapers then went back to work reconstructing the garden while Matthew concocted a plan. He grabbed a pickaxe and smashed it into the safe. It worked, and he was able to peer inside the box. What he saw gave him chills.

The Safe Contained Money And Jewels

The Safe Contained Money And Jewels
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter

Matthew Emanuel could hardly believe what he was seeing. Inside the safe were stacks of hundred dollar bills, each bundle at least three inches thick. There were also zipped plastic bags containing hundreds of valuables: chunks of gold, jade, earrings, jewels, and diamond rings were among the findings.

They had literally stumbled upon a real-life treasure in Matthew’s own backyard, right there among the fallen trees and destroyed garden. But there was one small issue.

The Money Had Server Water Damage

The Money Had Server Water Damage
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

Even though he finally figured out the true purpose of the old rusted box in his backyard, there was a problem. The safe was not waterproof and many of the bills were severely damaged from years of neglect and exposure to the New York elements.

The cash was squished together from bad water damage, and Matthew realized that he had to work quickly if he had any chance of saving some of the money.

Matthew Tried To Save What He Could Of The Money

Matthew Tried To Save What He Could Of The Money
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

Matthew set to work trying to salvage what he could of the water damaged money, pulling bills apart and setting them aside to dry. The project was tedious and took several days. As he soon discovered, he wasn’t able to save a large chunk of the treasure.

The bills were falling apart and were too ruined to be counted as legal currency. Even excluding the ruined billed, Matthew never expected the sum of the dried bills.

The Cash Equaled $16,300

The Cash Equaled $16,300
Jonathan Cutrer/Flickr
Jonathan Cutrer/Flickr

After everything was said and done, there was roughly $5,000 worth of bills that Matthew was unable to save. But then there was the rest of it. Albeit slightly faded, the newly dried cash came out to be $16,300. That’s not even counting what the jewels are worth!

Now that Matthew salvaged what he could from the safe, the mystery was over. Right? Nope! There was more that he had yet to learn about the mysterious safe.

The Safe Couldn’t Have Been A Coincidence

The Safe Couldn't Have Been A Coincidence
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

Even though it was exciting for Matthew and his family to find a real-life treasure, he was suspicious about how the safe came to be in the backyard. He felt as though it couldn’t be someone’s personal belongings that they put into a non-weather proof safe and forgot about either.

Although many people wouldn’t care about the safe’s origin, simply pocketing the findings and moving on, Matthew wasn’t finished. He believed there was something potentially illegal going on.

He Took Inventory Of The Other Riches

He Took Inventory Of The Other Riches
juliomaring/Youtube
juliomaring/Youtube

Now that the money was dried, Matthew’s next task was to take inventory of the rest of the riches. The amount of gold that was inside the safe was incredible and Matthew had to take out his kitchen scale just to make note of it all.

While he was in the middle of calculating and logging the rest of the safe’s contents, Matthew stumbled across something in one of the plastic bags that would change everything.

He Found An Adress

He Found An Adress
ABDULLAH HAMMAM/AFP/Getty Images
ABDULLAH HAMMAM/AFP/Getty Images

Putting the jewels aside, Matthew opened the bag to find a folded up piece of paper. It contained an address! Naturally, Matthew grabbed his phone to see where the address was located. Was it nearby?

The address could be for any number of locations but Matthew was hopeful that it led to the owner of the safe’s contents. After all, the address wouldn’t lead to the actual criminal, that’d be ridiculous! What he found during his GPS search left him shocked.

The Address On The Paper Was Close By

The Address On The Paper Was Close By
CBS New York/Youtube
CBS New York/Youtube

As it turned out, the address listed on the paper was very close by, enough so that Matthew wouldn’t even have to take his car. The owner of the old rusted safe’s contents wasn’t only on Staten Island but happened to be residing in the same neighborhood.

It dawned on Matthew that he had passed the house before, every time he walked his dog, as a matter of fact. It was then that Matthew knew what he had to do.

Matthew Was A Man On A Mission

Matthew Was A Man On A Mission
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

Matthew Emanuel couldn’t keep the contents of the safe to himself, not after he found the address. It wasn’t his property, after all. So on April 30, 2018, two days after opening the safe and discovering its contents, Matthew walked over to the address he found scrawled on the piece of paper.

He had no idea who was going to answer the door, or if they were even the true owners of the safe’s contents. Worst case scenario, if this meeting went downhill, he could get the police involved. So he knocked.

An Elderly Woman Opened the Door

An Elderly Woman Opened the Door
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter
Matthew Emanuel/Twitter

Matthew had no way of knowing who was going to open the door or what was going to happen during the very strange conversation revolving around a potential crime. Even so, he didn’t expect an elderly woman to open the door.

Not wanting to be rude, Matthew introduced himself and got right to it. He even went as far as to ask the already hesitant older woman a question, “Have you ever been robbed before?” She immediately started shaking, a reaction Matthew was not prepared for.

She And Her Husband Had Been Robbed Of $52,000

She And Her Husband Had Been Robbed Of $52,000
CBS News/Youtube
CBS News/Youtube

Matthew wasn’t sure if the woman was shaking due to excitement or pure terror. As it turns out, she confirmed Matthew suspicious; she had had indeed been robbed before. He couldn’t believe the story she was telling him about what happened years prior.

The night after Christmas 2011, a burglar broke into her home. By the time she and her husband had woken up, the criminal was long gone. The person had vanished along with $52,000 worth of money and jewelry.

The Ninja Burglar Prowled The Streets For Ten Years

The Ninja Burglar Prowled The Streets For Ten Years
Daily Mail/Youtube
Daily Mail/Youtube

Although Todt Hill is considered to be an affluent part of Staten Island, it has a frightening past. At the time of the elderly woman’s 2011 robbery, there was a masked person prowling the streets of the town. The press called him the “Ninja Burglar” because of his stealth and surprising success rate.

From 2005 to 2015, the Ninja Burglar robbed over 200 homes across Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey. 160 of those robberies being in Staten Island, many of which were in Todt Hill. Could this be his doing?

Robert Costanzo Was Finally Caught

Robert Costanzo
uscg/Pinterest
uscg/Pinterest

In 2015, the authorities arrested a man named Robert Costanzo in Staten Island. He had a criminal past and was in court for something unrelated to the burglaries when he was finally charged with the break-ins. It took two years, but Costanzo finally received a sentence of 22 years in prison.

Although many people could sleep easier knowing he was behind bars, the elderly lady Matthew found had long lost hope. Police told her that she was most likely never going to see her belongings again.

Matthew Took the Elderly Lady To His House

Matthew Took the Elderly Lady To His House
Daily Mail/Youtube
Daily Mail/Youtube

Now that he knew this old lady had been robbed a few years back, Matthew had no choice but to bring her to his home. He wanted to see if she’d be able to identify any of the jewelry. He was truly amazed by how fast everything was falling into place.

It’s unfortunate that the safe had been sitting in his backyard for all those years. Now he was so close to unraveling the mystery, and only after two days.

The Woman Was Filled With Emotions

The Woman Was Filled With Emotions
Jessie Jacobson/Flickr
Jessie Jacobson/Flickr

The moment the elderly lady saw the jewelry and stacks of cash on the counter she was overcome with emotion. She instantly started to cry and shake, all while hugging Matthew. Now they both knew the truth.

For six and a half years she had lived with the trauma of having some stranger in her home while she slept, losing her valuables, and being told over and over that she would never see them again.

Matthew Returns Everything To Its Rightful Owner

Matthew Returns Everything To Its Rightful Owner
CBS New York/Youtube
CBS New York/Youtube

Matthew Emanuel returned all of the safe’s contents to its rightful owner. What started off as an old rusted box, covered in poison ivy and foliage, and pretty much forgotten, had suddenly turned in to a momentous occasion in a mere few days.

With the help of a bad winter, hungry deer, and a curious landscaper called Bamboo Bob, Matthew was able to help a lady reclaim some of the lost valuables that were wrongfully taken from her, solving something that the police were unable to for more than six years.

Good Karma Was The Only Reward Matthew Wanted

citynews-torontGood Krama Was The Only Reward Matthew Wantedo-youtube-news
CityNews Toronto/Youtube
CityNews Toronto/Youtube

In his mind, there was no question of what he was going to do with the safe’s contents. Every piece of jewelry and each of the dollars he carefully separated and dried out were going to their true owner, his elderly neighbor. He also refused any type of award for returning the stolen items.

He told the press that they only reward he could hope for was good karma. After all, he was just doing the right thing! But he did make sure to do something so he never forgot the event.

An Elephant Statue To Replace The Mysterious Safe

An Elephant Statue To Replace The Mysterious Safe
CBS New York/Youtube
CBS New York/Youtube

Bamboo Bob had finished the backyard and the safe was back with its true owner. He and his family decided to commemorate the entire experience by placing a tiny ceramic elephant in the backyard by the bamboo.

They wanted to mark the spot of the safe, the memory of the mysterious box that was part of their yard for four years. And as a reminder that real-life mysteries can be solved and that treasure could be sitting right under your nose.

Internet Post About A Secret Room Goes Viral, Homeowner Didn’t Expect This

basement-reveal-01-92129
Imgur
Imgur

After moving into his first house in 2015, an Imgur user named Jerry shared his weird story of cleaning out the previous owner’s things. The old man had passed away, and the house was sold as-is, meaning it was in desperate need of some cleaning and a makeover.

As a first time homeowner, Jerry was okay with the house needing a little work. Little did he know exactly what he was getting himself into or what secrets he was about to discover.

Getting To Work On The Basement

stairway-to-basement-96633
Imgur
Imgur

After two weeks of moving his things into the house and starting some much-needed renovations, Jerry set his sights on the unfinished basement. In his post, he claimed that the basement was full of junk that needed to be tossed to make room for his belongings.

Since the previous owner didn’t have any family close enough to come over and remove the items, it was up to Jerry to remove them himself — and there was a lot of stuff!

A Secret Room Was Not Mentioned In The Listing

secret-door-basement-48804
Imgur
Imgur

While cleaning out the basement, Jerry noticed a large piece of plywood leaning up against the cinder block wall. Definitely out of place, he pried it off. Apparently the wood was hiding another room because Jerry discovered a gigantic hole in the wall where more cinder blocks should be.

As a new homeowner, finding a secret room that the real estate agent was unaware of was cause for a little bit of concern. What was inside?

A Crate, Boxes And Pouches Were Found

basement-reveal-76457
Imgur
Imgur

The four-by-four room was full of boxes, crates, and tiny pouches littered across the floor. The room wasn’t connected to the house’s electrical circuit, so Jerry had to run and grab a flashlight to see what was inside the creates.

The place almost seemed like a bunker of sorts, but that didn’t make sense. Why wasn’t it cleaned out? It looked as though no one had been there in ages. Is it possible that the previous owner was hiding something?

Of Course, There’s A Secret Safe In The Secret Room

basement-reveal-02-57843
Imgur
Imgur

“At this point, I am a little shocked, and a little scared,” Jerry wrote. Curiosity got the better of him and he climbed through the small hole. The first thing he noticed in the tiny room were the gun casings stacked on top of one another. They were empty but plentiful. Why hoard empty casings?

That’s when he noticed something in the corner of the room. A Sentry safe, heavy and completely locked.

To Open The Safe Or Not To Open The Safe

basement-reveal-03-80628
Imgur
Imgur

Jerry wasn’t sure what to do. Should he call the previous owner’s children to see if they know anything about the safe or the secret room? What if they wanted some of the items that were stored away?

He decided he was going to try and open the safe. Although it’s a bit unethical, the safe is technically his since he bought the house as-is. The only issue being, what if he finds something bad?

The Safe Isn’t Even His Most Interesting Find

basement-reveal-04-57823
Imgur
Imgur

He put opening the safe on the back burner, deciding to investigate the contents in the room a bit further. That’s when he found hundreds of live rounds of ammunition. The scary part? They were all in unlocked cases and obviously stored here by the previous owner.

Jerry couldn’t tell if it was a collection or if they were hidden away in the basement for some alternative reason. Unfortunately, he was about to find out.

Dreaming Of Stolen Merchandise And Basements

basement-reveal-05-50138
Imgur
Imgur

After further exploration, Jerry found more army-style bins that held similar items like the ammo. He called it a night, deciding that he would come back to the secret room in the morning. It was a lot to wrap his head around.

He would be in the right mood to tear apart the room after a good night’s sleep.He wondered what types of secrets and treasures were in the basement. What on Earth did he stumble across down there?

He Stumbled Across Military-Grade Equipment

basement-reveal-07-17858
Imgur
Imgur

The next day brought new revelations to Jerry. He climbed back into the room to investigate the numerous boxes and crates scattered around, only to realize that most of them were labeled as military-grade.

Why would an old man have all of this military equipment? Jerry knew right then that he had to open the containers to see what lied inside. The thing is, he was not prepared for what he found.

Civilian Marksmanship Program

basement-reveal-08-48299
Imgur
Imgur

He found an empty rifle case that was marked “Civilian Marksmanship Program,” meaning the previous homeowner knew how to use these guns. Something wasn’t right, the previous owner wasn’t just collecting the guns and ammo, he was using them.

Maybe he had special military permission to have the items in his house? That didn’t seem right either, so Jerry decided to open the crates. The contents almost had him running out of the room…

Way More Ammo Than Any Civilian Needs

basement-reveal-09.jpg-67331
Imgur
Imgur

Things got a lot more serious after Jerry opened the crates. Hidden in the room was an SKS air rifle, crates of blank ammo, two crates of rifle ammo, a box of 19mm military-grade ammo, a box of 8mm ammo, boxes of Wolf 39mm ammo, and a dead grenade.

That’s a lot of ammo for an old man. Why was it hidden away? The weirdest part is that Jerry’s strangest discovery is the most harmless.

Pennies?

basement-reveal-10.jpg-44961
Imgur
Imgur

In one of the crates, he stashed a boat-load of pennies! So what was the connection between all of the military equipment and the pennies? They must be worth something, why else would he store such a large quantity?

They were worth hiding for some reason, Jerry just couldn’t figure out why. His concern started growing as he tried to figure out why the previous owner was hiding all of these things in the basement.

The End Of The World Is Upon Us

basement-reveal-11-48184
Imgur
Imgur

Maybe they were doomsday “preppers.” People who like to be super prepared for the inevitable collapse of society because of war, a natural disaster, or the zombie apocalypse. They usually stockpile ammo and guns. But wouldn’t there be canned goods and water, too?

Also, some collectors like to save pennies from pre-1980s because they were made out of copper. Something that could be used for trade, in case the dollar loses its value in the world.

Time To Circle Back To The Safe

basement-reveal-12-74199
Imgur
Imgur

Now, back to the creepy, heavy-duty safe in the corner. Jerry couldn’t move it due to the weight, so he was going to have to figure out how to open it in the room. Cracking the code was out of the question, so he gathered his father’s tools to try and pry it open.

After spending way more time trying to pry the safe open than he would like to admit, Jerry finally called a locksmith.

Any Ideas Of What The Old Man Locked Away?

basement-reveal-13-93672
Imgur
Imgur

Jerry took to his Imgur thread that was now gaining an audience following, telling everyone that the locksmith was going to come by the up-coming Monday and to stay tuned for an update. Seemed as though everyone was excited to see what was inside!

If the old man thought it was fine to leave military-grade guns and ammunition out in the open, what could he possibly have that warranted him locking it away?

And Then There Was Silence

basement-reveal-14-73017
Imgur
Imgur

That was the last time the Imgur thread heard from Jerry. After the radio silence, the internet world began to hypothesize what happened to him. Some say he got the safe open, found a ton of cash, ditched the thread, and ran. Others say the viral story gave him some unwanted attention and that Jerry posted something he shouldn’t have

Little did the spectators know that the latter is relatively close to the truth.

He Lives!

basement-reveal-15-89305
Imgur
Imgur

After two years, Jerry took to the thread again, his subject heading reading, “UPDATE: If anyone remembers or cares.” He dives into the scary story of what his life had been like for the past couple of years.

Crazy things began to happen to him after the posts went viral, forcing him to go into hiding for years before feeling comfortable enough to go back online to finish his tale of the secret room.

Weird People And Late Night Disturbances

basement-reveal-16-67659
Imgur
Imgur

First, two days after posting the story, strange-looking people rang the doorbell. Having no idea who they were or what they wanted, he didn’t answer the door. They stuck around for a few minutes before getting in their car and leaving.

The next night, something startled him awake, and his dog began to growl. That’s when something either hit his house or someone knocked on a door or window. Who does that in the middle of the night?

Wrongful Break-in Made Him Paranoid

basement-reveal-17-60215
Imgur
Imgur

Two nights later, someone broke into Jerry’s neighbor’s house. Nothing was stolen, but it was very clear that the intruders were looking for something specific. It may have been pure coincidence, but Jerry is fairly sure the people who broke in next door thought they were breaking into his house.

What if they were tech-savvy enough to track where the posts were coming from? Thankfully, no one had been hurt, but Jerry was beyond paranoid.

After That Fiasco, It’s No Wonder He Moved Out

basement-reveal-18-37925
Imgur
Imgur

Jerry told his followers that he would not reveal what he found in the safe, saying that he’s too paranoid about posting it online after everything that happened to him.

He has since moved out of the house, not wanting the new owners to go through what he did. The world may never know what the old man was actually preparing for, and the ending of this freaky tale leaves us with more questions than answers.