These Hit Songs Were Meant For Other Artists And We Can’t Stop Thinking About What Could Have Been

Hilary Duff And P!nk Were Offered ‘Since U Been Gone’

Photo credit: Kelly Clarkson / YouTube

Hilary Duff and P!nk were both offered “Since U Been Gone,” and I have mixed feelings about it. The song would never work with Duff’s squeaky-clean Disney reputation, but P!nk might have been able to pull it off.

When Kelly Clarkson released it in 2004, it was a sign of her graduating from American Idol princess to an angsty, chart-topping singer.